There has been a lot of conversations about disciplinary literacy in recent months in my professional learning circles. The intent is sometimes going in strange directions in math class towards keywords in word problems and being “ok with writing just to write”. The whole “incorporating reading and writing into the math class” treats the matter as if reading and writing skills are somehow not intrinsic to math and have to be dragged in forcefully.
There is a lot of reading, writing, questioning, inquiring and thinking critically that absolutely has to happen in a math class for students to learn math in a meaningful way. And I also think that often math topics can lead into some great creative writing, art and discoveries across the disciplines. This post is about the latter.
I have blogged extensively about my geometry lessons this year (here and here). I am working with an amazing teaching partner this year, who is taking care of the language arts teaching part of our fifty students’ community. Working with Megan allowed me to regularly cross the imaginary boarders between the subjects without any teachers being hurt in the process. She developed and implemented the writing/reading part of this polygons project.
Polygons Pen Pals
Students have been exploring, classifying and creating their own polygons from tangrams. I noticed some started drawing eyes and hands, and that’s how the project was born. After identifying the properties of their polygons, students gave them names and considered their personalities and life stories.They wrote letters to their unknown polygon pen pals, and next week we hope to exchange the letters and to write responses. I will leave the rest of this post to my students’ work.
SKITTLES
LARRY’S SWORD
LARRY
SHIRO
LARRYO
BOB
LINDSAY
CENAMAN
QUAD QUADRILATERAL
KASEY
Thoughts and Questions
I know that students enjoyed giving “life” and stories to their polygons. I admit my worries that it might have been a superficial connection. There was no mathematical need for written communication and there are still many questions that I wonder about.
Did moving towards creative writing still support my students’ mathematical thinking in some way?
What is the value in putting mathematical objects and relationships into non-mathematical context?
Months later, my students keep bringing up our infinity art/writing/reading lessons; they keep asking mathematical questions and making mathematical connections. My students spent time thinking about dragons and favorite food of their polygons, but they were also very careful making sure they identified their polygons’ “physical” features correctly. Mathematical context created motivation for creative writing which in turn created motivation for mathematical precision. Maybe we do need the whole range of experiences to make sense of the whole range of things and our literacies can be a bit more interdisciplinary.
‘I noticed some started drawing eyes and hands, and that’s how the project was born.’
If we’re to really find a place for student initiative, playfulness, creativity, then we need lots of projects like this, that come from noticing what our students do, and giving them time to do it more.
As for the maths, I think there’s an affective thing here, that should be part of our teaching- the emotions. They’ve created and adopted a polygon as a pet, given it life and personality. Alongside the mathematical description of the polygon, they’ve brought their shape to life. Shapes get damaged when they’re treated as obligations, as form-filling exercises: Number of sides? 5 Acute angle? Yes. Etc, etc. I can’t help but think that this will be memorable for lots of them, just as the infinity question has been.
And of course as a literacy task, well, you need as many of these playful opportunities for short pieces of writing as possible. It’s interesting that a lot of the children seem – I’m guessing – to have put something a little autobiographical into their writing too!
Almost every piece of writing has something I want to ask about. What shape clothes does Shiro’s cat dress up in? What kind of structures would Bob build? Is Quad Quadrilateral interested in the seasons partly because there are four of them?
By the way, what do you want to be when you grow up? I know what I want to be. I want to be a shape nurse. Because you can heal a lot of shapes and polygons.
LikeLike